Implicit differentiation and related rates AA HL
Implicit differentiation finds a gradient when is not written on its own, and related rates use the same idea with time as the variable. The first section shows how to differentiate every term, rearrange for the gradient and use it for tangents, normals and second derivatives. The second shows how to link two changing quantities with one equation, differentiate it with respect to time and substitute at the end. Most questions are exact and need no calculator, so practise the algebra by hand.
Formulas at a glance
The power rule, standard derivatives, chain rule, product rule, quotient rule, the equation of a line through a point and the area, volume and surface area formulas for circles and solids are in the formula booklet. Differentiating a power of , and linking two rates through time, are not: both come from the chain rule, so build them from it each time.
Power rule
In the bookletStandard derivatives
In the bookletChain rule
In the bookletProduct rule
In the bookletQuotient rule
In the bookletDifferentiating a power of with respect to
Not in the bookletEquation of a tangent through with gradient
In the bookletLinking two rates through time
Not in the bookletArea of a circle
In the bookletVolume of a sphere
In the bookletSurface area of a sphere
In the bookletVolume of a cone
In the bookletWhich method to use
Decide whether the question is about a curve at one moment, where is the variable, or about quantities changing with time, where is the variable. Then look at what is given.
| The question has | Use | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| An equation in and with not on its own, and wanted | Differentiate every term with respect to , adding a factor to each term in | Collect the terms on one side, factorise, then divide |
| A term such as or | The product rule, with coming from the factor | Do not treat the factor as a constant |
| A gradient, tangent or normal at a point on the curve | Substitute both coordinates into , then use | For a normal, use as the gradient |
| A second derivative of an implicit curve | Differentiate implicitly again, then replace with the first result | The original equation often simplifies the final answer |
| Two quantities changing with time, and the rate of one is wanted | One equation linking them, differentiated with respect to | Substitute the known values only after differentiating |
| The area or volume of a circle or solid changing | The booklet formula and the chain rule, for example | Keep the radius as a variable until the derivative is taken |
| A right-angled triangle whose sides change, such as a sliding ladder | Pythagoras' theorem, differentiated with respect to | A length that is getting shorter has a negative rate |
| A person or point moving along a line, with a shadow or other similar triangles | Similar triangles to link the lengths, then differentiate with respect to | Read whether the question asks for the speed of the tip or the rate of change of the length |
Section 1 of 2 AHL5.14 AHL5.12
Implicit differentiation
Implicit differentiation finds for a relation in which is not written as a function of , such as . Differentiate every term with respect to , remembering that each term gains a factor of , then rearrange to make the subject. It also covers products such as and gradients at a point.
The method
There is no separate formula to learn here: implicit differentiation is a technique built entirely from the chain rule, so it is not listed in the formula booklet.
Implicit differentiation
Differentiate both sides of an equation in and with respect to . Because is itself a function of , every -term picks up a factor from the chain rule. Once every term is differentiated, rearrange to isolate .
Not in the formula booklet - techniqueMixed terms need the product rule too
A term like contains both variables, so differentiate it as a product: . Then collect every term on one side and factorise before dividing through.
Useful for tangent and normal problems on circles and other implicitly defined curves. For a second derivative, differentiate your expression for implicitly again, then replace each in the result with the first derivative.
Key terms
What is an implicit relation?
It is an equation in which and are mixed together and is not isolated. Some implicit relations cannot be rearranged into the form .
e.g. is implicit, whereas is written explicitly.
How do you differentiate ?
is a product of two functions of , so use the product rule. The factor gives a term.
e.g. .
How do you make the subject?
After differentiating, collect every term containing on one side, factorise it out, then divide.
e.g. For , differentiating gives , so .
How do you find the gradient at a point on an implicit curve?
After isolating , substitute both the -coordinate and the -coordinate of the point, because the expression usually contains both.
e.g. For , , so at the gradient is .
Worked example, step by step
The question No calculator needed [6 marks]
The curve has equation . The point lies on .
(a) Find in terms of and .
(b) Find the equation of the normal to at , giving your answer in the form , where , and are integers.
Worked solution: worked example
Answer: (a) (b)
Step 1 - Differentiate every term with respect to .
The term is a product, so Therefore M1 - Differentiate with respect to , using the product rule and a factor on each term in A1 -
Why? Because is a function of , the chain rule gives each term in a factor . The product rule handles , where both factors vary.
Step 2 - Make the subject.
Collect the terms that contain and factorise: M1 - Collect and factorise the terms A1 -
Why? The terms are on one side and everything else is on the other, so a single division finishes part (a).
Step 3 - Find the gradient of the tangent at .
Substitute and :
Why? The expression contains both and , so both coordinates of are needed.
Step 4 - Find the gradient of the normal.
The normal is perpendicular to the tangent, so its gradient is the negative reciprocal of , which is . M1 - Substitute to find the tangent gradient and take the negative reciprocal
Why? Perpendicular lines have gradients whose product is . Turning the fraction upside down and changing the sign gives it.
Step 5 - Write the equation of the normal.
A1 -
Why? Multiply by to clear the fraction, then collect everything on one side to meet the form . The point gives , as it should.
M1 Differentiate with respect to , using the product rule and a factor on each term in
A1
M1 Collect and factorise the terms
A1
M1 Substitute to find the tangent gradient and take the negative reciprocal
A1
Now you try: enter your answers to be marked
These are real practice questions. Type your answer in each box and press Mark it. The worked solution and mark scheme appear straight away, and your first attempt is the one that counts. Use the keyboard for powers, roots and trig, and the working box for your notes.
Worked solution: practice question 1
Find in terms of only, giving your answer in simplified form.
Worked solution: practice question 2
Worked solution: practice question 3
Your score so far: 0 out of 17 marks
Common mistakes
- Dropping on a y-term. Every term containing needs a factor from the chain rule - forgetting it on even one term gives a completely wrong equation to rearrange.
- Treating as a simple product of constants. A mixed term like needs the product rule, not just "differentiate , differentiate " - the correct result is , not .
- Stopping before isolating . After differentiating, the terms are usually scattered across the equation - you must collect them, factorise, and divide before the answer is complete.
Syllabus content covered
| Code | Syllabus content |
|---|---|
| AHL5.12 | Higher derivatives. Familiarity with the notations , . |
| AHL5.14 | Implicit differentiation. Related rates of change. Appropriate use of the chain rule or implicit differentiation. |
Official IB source: Mathematics: analysis and approaches subject brief (PDF, ibo.org).
Quick questions
What is implicit differentiation?
A way of differentiating an equation in and that isn't rearranged into . You differentiate both sides with respect to , applying the chain rule so every -term gains a factor, then rearrange to isolate .
How do I set up a related rates of change problem?
Write a fixed equation connecting the quantities involved - Pythagoras' theorem, a volume or area formula, similar triangles or a trigonometric relationship. Then differentiate both sides implicitly with respect to time and substitute the known rate and value to solve for the unknown rate.
Why does differentiating a y-term give a dy/dx?
Because is itself a function of , so differentiating any expression in with respect to needs the chain rule: .
Why can't I substitute the known values before differentiating?
Substituting a fixed value too early turns a variable into a constant, so its derivative silently disappears from the equation. Differentiate the whole connecting equation first, with every quantity still a variable, and only substitute known numbers afterwards.
How do I find the equation of a tangent to an implicit curve?
Find , substitute the coordinates of the point to get the gradient , then use .
Should the answer to a related rates question be positive or negative?
The sign shows direction: a positive rate means the quantity is increasing and a negative rate means it is decreasing. If a question asks how fast something is falling, a negative value such as m/s means it is falling at m/s.
Why do both x and y appear in my expression for dy/dx?
The relation does not give as a function of , so the gradient generally depends on both coordinates. Substitute both values to find the gradient at a point.
What if the equation has more variables than I have rates for?
Use the geometry to eliminate a variable before differentiating, as long as you substitute a relationship and not a particular value. For a cone with , the volume becomes , which has only one variable besides .
When does an implicit curve have a vertical tangent?
Where the denominator of is zero and the numerator is not. For , is undefined at , which gives the points .
What units does a related rate have?
The unit is the unit of the quantity divided by the unit of time. A volume measured in , changing with time measured in seconds, has a rate in .
Ready to practise properly?
Practice questions on every section, marked instantly like the real exam.